Faculty/staff leadership
| Interim president | Alex Sider, PhD | |
| Interim vice president and dean of academic affairs | Gayle Trollinger, PhD | |
| Interim vice president of advancement and enrollment management | Claire Kleman, MBA | |
| Vice president for fiscal affairs | John Burkhart, CMA | |
| Vice president of student affairs and athletics |
Phill Talavinia, MBA |
| Business | Jonathan Andreas, Ph.D. | |
| Communication and fine arts | Melissa Friesen Ph.D. | |
| Education | Gayle Trollinger, Ph.D. | |
| Health, fitness and sports science | Tami Forbes, M.S. | |
| Health sciences, natural sciences and mathematics | Angie Montel, Ph.D. | |
| Humanities | Martina Cucchiara, Ph.D. | |
| Social sciences and social work | Michael Barrett, M.A.Ed. |
| Assessment and ADA coordinator | Alex Sider, Ph.D. | |
| Bluffton University Research Center (BURC) | TBD | |
| Educator preparation director | Gayle Trollinger, Ph.D. | |
| General education | Marathana Prothro | |
| Global education | Paul Neufeld Weaver, Ed.D. | |
| Graduate programs in business | Brienne Sprunger | |
| Graduate program – Collaborative MBA | Jonathan Andreas, Ph.D. | |
| Graduate program in dietetics | Bethany Dario, MPH, RDN, LD | |
| Graduate programs in education | Amy Mullins, Ph.D. | |
| Graduate program in social work | Dr. Jeanette Harder, MSW, Ph.D. | |
| Honors program | Martina Cucchiara, Ph.D. & Luke Myers, Ph.D. | |
| Learning Resource Center (LRC) | Jacqui Slinger | |
| Library | Carrie Phillips, M.L.I.S. | |
| Nursing | Dr. Ruth Myers | |
| Social work (undergraduate) | Walt Paquin, Ph.D., L.I.S.W. | |
| Speech-language pathology and audiology | Tina Juarez, M.A. | |
| Writing Center | Cindy Bandish, Ph.D. |
| Art | Andi Baumgartner, M.F.A. | |
| Biology | Angie Montel, Ph.D. | |
| Business undergraduate | Jonathan Andreas, Ph.D. | |
| Chemistry | Charles Daws, Ph.D. | |
| Communication | Melissa Friesen, Ph.D. | |
| Forum | Gerald Mast , Ph.D. |
| Athletics director | James Grandey | |
| Buildings and grounds operations manager | Steven Heinze | |
| Dean of students | Mark Bourassa | |
| Director of Center for Career and Vocation | Chalsi Campbell | |
| Director of community life/Title IX coordinator | Megan Coffman | |
| Director of financial aid | Jayme Jarrett | |
| Director of institutional research | Samantha Shrider | |
| Director of residence life | Michael Bryan | |
| Director of student success | Christy Garmatter | |
| Registrar | Cindy Bandish |