| All Time School Records | ||||
| Total | Name | Year | ||
| Most Goals- Season | 26 | Aaron Madrigal | 1999 | |
| Most Assists-Season | 15 | Josh Gaines | 1993 | |
| Most Steals-Season | 74 | Tyler Gleason | 2004 | |
| Most Intercepts-Season | 182 | Tyler Gleason | 2002 | |
| Most Shutouts-Season | 14 | Matt Renfrow | 1999 | |
| Most Goals-Game | 5 | Gavin Stumbaugh | 2000 | |
| Most Assists-Game | 6 | Dan Lee | 1993 | |
| Most Steals-Game | 13 | Sawyer Goldsberry | 2004 | |
| Most Intercepts-Game | 22 | Tyler Gleason | 2002 | |
| Fewest Goals Allowed-Seas | 10 | 1999 | ||
| Most Career Goals | 37 | Aaron Madrigal | 97-99 | |
| Most Career Assists | 35 | Josh Gaines | 92-94 | |
| Most Career Steals | 170 | Tyler Gleason | 2001-2004 | |
| Most Career Intercepts | 474 | Tyler Gleason | 2001-2004 | |
| Most Career Shutouts | 30 | Matt Renfrow | 97-99 | |
| MVP Offense | MVP Defense | 110% Award | Pirate Award | |
| 1992 | Dan Lee | Dan Bishop | Jared Reichenbach | Dan Lee |
| 1993 | Josh Gaines | Brian Garrett | Dan Bishop | Jared Reichenbach |
| 1994 | Josh Gaines | Mike Powell | Joel Steinmetz | Mike Powell |
| 1995 | Joe Barhorst | Eric Garrett | Ryan Badertscher | Gabe Benroth |
| 1996 | Casey Cherry | Adam Byers | Ben Hart | Casey Cherry |
| 1997 | Michael Kingsley | Peter Bixel | Adam Byers | Brendon Matthews |
| 1998 | Josh August | Kurt McKibben | Josh Boehr | Josh Boehr |
| 1999 | Aaron Madrigal | Mark Brauen | Ryan Dunlap | Jeremy Parkins |
| 2000 | Gavin Stumbaugh | Brett Buller | David Shields | Matt Renfrow |
| 2001 | Ben Gundy | Whit Goldsberry | Garrett Stumbaugh | Whit Goldsberry |
| 2002 | Garrett Stumbaugh | Tyler Gleason | Steven Ford | Andy Marquart |
| 2003 | Zach Bingham | Tyler Gleason | Micah Boehr | Micah Boehr |
| 1995 | All-State | Eric Garrett | ||
| 1997 | All-State | Brendon Matthews | ||
| 1998 | All-State | Jeremy Parkins | ||
| 1999 | All-State | Jeremy Parkins/Matt Renfrow | ||
| 2000 | All-State | Matt Renfrow | ||