| Date | Location | Result | |
| 11-12-09 | Holland, Mich. | Ohio Northern 3, Bluffton 1 (20-25,25-23,25-16,25-17) | Box score |
| 11-08-09 | Bluffton, Ohio | Bluffton 3, Mt. St. Joseph 2 (22-25,13-25,26-24,25-18,15-12) | Box score |
| 11-07-09 | Bluffton, Ohio | Bluffton 3, Defiance 1 (25-15,25-17,23-25,25-13) | Box score |
| 11-03-09 | Bluffton, Ohio | Bluffton University 3, Defiance College 0 (25-15,25-23,25-17) | Box score |
| 11-01-09 | Defiance, Ohio | Bluffton University 3, Franklin College 0 (25-10,25-11,25-13) | Box score |
| 10-31-09 | Terra Haute, Ind. | Bluffton University 3, Illinois College 1 (25-15,25-23,16-25,25-21) | Box score |
| 10-31-09 | Terre Haute, Ind. | Bluffton University 3, Rose-Hulman 0 (25-21,29-27,27-25) | Box score |
| 10-27-09 | Adrian, Mich. | Bluffton University 3, Adrian College 1 (20-25,25-20,25-13,25-20) | Box score |
| 10-24-09 | Lexington, KY | Bluffton University 3, Asbury College 1 (25-16,25-22,23-25,25-14) | Box score |
| 10-24-09 | Lexington, KY | Bluffton University 3, Transylvania U. 0 (25-18,25-20,25-12) | Box score |
| 10-23-09 | Cincinnati, Ohio | Bluffton University 3, Cincinnati Christian 0 (25-15,25-20,25-20) | Box score |
| 10-17-09 | Bluffton, Ohio | Bluffton University 3, Otterbein College 0 (25-22,26-24,25-19) | Box score |
| 10-17-09 | Bluffton, Ohio | Bluffton University 3, Grace College 0 (25-9,25-21,25-20) | Box score |
| 10-14-09 | North Manchester, IN | Bluffton University 3, Manchester College 0 (25-9,25-15,25-14) | Box score |
| 10-08-09 | Bluffton, Ohio | Bluffton University 3, Anderson University 0 (25-9,25-19,25-23) | Box score |
| 10-03-09 | Bluffton, Ohio | Bluffton University 3, Hanover College 1 (17-25,25-20,25-13,25-23) | Box score |
| 10-02-09 | Bluffton, Ohio | Bluffton University 3, Mt. St. Joseph 0 (25-20,25-19,25-18) | Box score |
| 09-30-09 | Bluffton, Ohio | Bluffton University 3, Wilmington College 0 (25-12,25-20,25-19) | Box score |
| 09-27-09 | Cincinnati, OH | Marietta College 3, Bluffton University 0 (27-25,25-19,26-24) | Box score |
| 09-27-09 | Cincinnati, OH | Ohio Northern 3, Bluffton University 1 (19-25,25-18,25-19,25-18) | Box score |
| 09-26-09 | Mt. St. Joseph | Bluffton University 3, Otterbein College 2 (25-20,18-25,22-25,25-23,15-8) | Box score |
| 09-26-09 | Mt. St. Joseph | Bluffton University 3, Baldwin Wallace 1 (25-15,25-19,23-25,25-13) | Box score |
| 09-22-09 | Oberlin, OH | Bluffton University 3, Oberlin College 2 (25-23,18-25,25-17,21-25,15-8) | Box score |
| 09-16-09 | Bluffton, Ohio | Ohio Northern 3, Bluffton University 1 (24-26,25-16,25-23,25-17) | Box score |
| 09-12-09 | Kenyon College | Bluffton University 3, Ursuline College 0 (25-19,25-17,25-17) | Box score |
| 09-12-09 | Kenyon College | Bluffton University 3, Kenyon College 1 (19-25,25-8,25-11,25-19) | Box score |
| 09-11-09 | Kenyon College | Bluffton University 3, John Carroll 0 (25-14,25-17,25-20) | Box score |
| 09-11-09 | Kenyon College | Bluffton University 3, Sewanee of the South 0 (25-11,25-12,25-16) | Box score |
| 09-09-09 | Bluffton, Ohio | Bluffton University 3, Ohio Wesleyan 0 (25-21,25-17,25-18) | Box score |
| 09-05-09 | River Forest, Ill. | Clarke College 3, Bluffton University 2 (20-25,25-22,25-21,11-25,15-13) | Box score |
| 09-05-09 | River Forest, Ill. | Hamline University 3, Bluffton University 2 (25-20,25-27,25-20,17-25,17-15) | Box score |
| 09-04-09 | River Forest, Ill. | Bluffton University 3, Dominican University 1 (16-25,25-20,25-14,25-16) | Box score |
| 09-04-09 | River Forest, Ill. | Bluffton University 3, Coe College 0 (25-17,28-26,25-15) | Box score |