| Date | Location | Result | |
| 02-24-12 | Beck Center/Lexington, Ky. | Anderson 69, Bluffton University 67 | Box score |
| 02-18-12 | Bluffton, Ohio (Founders Hall) | Bluffton University 83, Transylvania 65 | Box score |
| 02-15-12 | Defiance, OH | Defiance College 55, Bluffton University 53 | Box score |
| 02-11-12 | Collier Arena - Hanover, Ind. | Bluffton University 51, Hanover College 48 | Box score |
| 02-08-12 | Bluffton, Ohio (Founders Hall) | Manchester 63, Bluffton University 62 | Box score |
| 02-04-12 | Bluffton, Ohio (Founders Hall) | Anderson 70, Bluffton University 67 | Box score |
| 02-01-12 | Bluffton, Ohio (Founders Hall) | Bluffton University 74, College of Mount St. Joseph 64 | Box score |
| 01-28-12 | Spurlock Center; Franklin, Ind. | Bluffton University 65, Franklin College 57 | Box score |
| 01-25-12 | Richmond, Indiana | Bluffton University 73, Earlham College 72 | Box score |
| 01-21-12 | Bluffton, Ohio (Founders Hall) | Bluffton University 62, Rose-Hulman 56 | Box score |
| 01-18-12 | N. Manchester, Ind./Stauffer-Wolfe Arena | Manchester 59, Bluffton University 58 | Box score |
| 01-14-12 | O.C. Lewis Gymnasium, Anderson, Ind. | Bluffton University 77, Anderson 70 | Box score |
| 01-11-12 | Bluffton, Ohio (Founders Hall) | Bluffton University 77, Earlham College 73 | Box score |
| 01-07-12 | Bluffton, Ohio (Founders Hall) | Hanover College 75, Bluffton University 61 | Box score |
| 01-04-12 | Bluffton, Ohio (Founders Hall) | Bluffton University 73, Defiance College 67 | Box score |
| 12-30-11 | Bluffton, Ohio (Founders Hall) | Bluffton University 87, Grove City 68 | Box score |
| 12-29-11 | Bluffton, Ohio (Founders Hall) | Bluffton University 94, Ohio State-Lima 54 | Box score |
| 12-17-11 | Beck Center/Lexington, Ky. | Transylvania 76, Bluffton University 68 | Box score |
| 12-10-11 | Terre Haute, Ind. - Hulbert Arena | Rose-Hulman 66, Bluffton University 55 | Box score |
| 12-07-11 | Anderson Athletic Center, Kalamazoo, MI | Kalamazoo College 75, Bluffton University 66 | Box score |
| 12-03-11 | Bluffton, Ohio (Founders Hall) | Franklin College 82, Bluffton University 79 | Box score |
| 11-30-11 | Cincinnati, OH (MSJ Harrington Center) | Bluffton University 52, College of Mount St. Joseph 39 | Box score |
| 11-26-11 | Bluffton, Ohio (Founders Hall) | Bluffton University 73, Hiram College 68 | Box score |
| 11-23-11 | Bluffton, Ohio (Founders Hall) | Bluffton University 74, Ohio Mid-Western 61 | Box score |
| 11-20-11 | Grant Gymnasium | Bluffton University 97, Rust College 94 | Box score |
| 11-19-11 | Grant Gymnasium | Bluffton University 79, WUMB 76 | Box score |