| Date | Location | Result | |
| 05-05-12 | Bluffton, Ohio | Hanover College 7, Bluffton University 5 | Box score |
| 05-04-12 | Bluffton, Ohio | Bluffton University 5, Hanover College 4 | Box score |
| 05-04-12 | Bluffton, Ohio | Bluffton University 7, Hanover College 1 | Box score |
| 04-29-12 | Franklin, Ind. | Franklin 7, Bluffton University 4 | Box score |
| 04-29-12 | Franklin, Ind. | Bluffton University 8, Franklin 3 | Box score |
| 04-28-12 | Franklin, Ind. | Franklin 4, Bluffton University 0 | Box score |
| 04-24-12 | Richmond, Indiana | Bluffton University 11, Earlham College 2 | Box score |
| 04-22-12 | Bluffton, Ohio | Mount St. Joseph 6, Bluffton University 3 | Box score |
| 04-21-12 | Bluffton, Ohio | Bluffton University 6, Mount St. Joseph 5 | Box score |
| 04-21-12 | Bluffton, Ohio | Mount St. Joseph 2, Bluffton University 1 | Box score |
| 04-17-12 | Bluffton, Ohio | Defiance 5, Bluffton University 4 | Box score |
| 04-14-12 | Anderson, Ind. | Bluffton University 15, Anderson 7 | Box score |
| 04-14-12 | Anderson, Ind. | Anderson 8, Bluffton University 6 | Box score |
| 04-13-12 | Anderson, Ind. | Anderson 12, Bluffton University 8 | Box score |
| 04-10-12 | Bluffton, Ohio | Bluffton University 8, Earlham College 7 | Box score |
| 04-07-12 | Bluffton, Ohio | Bluffton University 14, Transylvania 4 | Box score |
| 03-07-12 | Bluffton, Ohio | Transylvania 11, Bluffton University 2 | Box score |
| 04-06-12 | Bluffton, Ohio | Bluffton University 13, Transylvania 8 | Box score |
| 04-03-12 | Defiance, Ohio | Bluffton University 10, Defiance 2 | Box score |
| 04-01-12 | Terre Haute, Ind. | Rose-Hulman 4, Bluffton University 3 | Box score |
| 03-31-12 | Terre Haute, Ind. | Rose-Hulman 7, Bluffton University 4 | Box score |
| 03-31-12 | Terre Haute, Ind. | Bluffton University 3, Rose-Hulman 1 | Box score |
| 03-27-12 | Bluffton, Ohio | Bluffton University 13, Denison University 9 | Box score |
| 03-25-12 | N. Manchester, Ind | Bluffton University 2, Manchester 1 | Box score |
| 03-24-12 | N. Manchester, Ind | Manchester 17, Bluffton University 5 | Box score |
| 03-24-12 | N. Manchester, Ind. | Manchester 6, Bluffton University 0 | Box score |
| 03-20-12 | Bluffton, Ohio | Bluffton University 18, Ohio Northern 8 | Box score |
| 03-17-12 | Bluffton, Ohio | Bluffton University 15, Albion College 5 | Box score |
| 03-17-12 | Bluffton, Ohio | Albion College 6, Bluffton University 4 | Box score |
| 03-14-12 | Oberlin, Ohio | Bluffton University 5, Oberlin College 4 | Box score |
| 03-09-12 | Port Charlotte, FL | John Carroll 13, Bluffton University 8 | Box score |
| 03-09-12 | Port Charlotte, FL | Bluffton University 5, Muskingum University 1 | Box score |
| 03-08-12 | Port Charlotte, FL | Baldwin-Wallace 3, Bluffton University 1 | Box score |
| 03-07-12 | Port Charlotte, FL | Heidelberg 5, Bluffton University 4 | Box score |
| 03-06-12 | Port Charlotte, FL | John Carroll 8, Bluffton University 4 | Box score |
| 03-05-12 | Port Charlotte, FL | Bluffton University 12, Muskingum University 8 | Box score |
| 03-04-12 | Port Charlotte, FL | Baldwin-Wallace 17, Bluffton University 5 | Box score |
| 03-04-12 | Port Charlotte, FL | Bluffton University 8, John Carroll 5 | Box score |
| 02-25-12 | Chillicothe, Ohio | Ohio Wesleyan 7, Bluffton University 1 | Box score |
| 02-25-12 | Chillicothe, Ohio | Ohio Wesleyan 6, Bluffton University 5 | Box score |